 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
All Categories • Continuing Committee • Organized Play • Rules Committee • Deck Designs • Virtual Expansions
Card Extras • Special Events • Tournament Reports • Everything Else • Spotlight Series • Contests
Strategy Articles
Make it So Challenge #6 Results
by Charlie Plaine, Make it So Host
28th February 2014
Gray Matters, the sixth challenge (the second of the team phase) challenged each team with creating six (6) new cards to enhance, augment, or otherwise "improve" a subset of dilemmas of their own choosing. The downloader dilemmas and dilemma enhancers that first appeared in Shades of Gray were given as examples, but teams were given a great deal of freedom in deciding which dilemmas to improve, and how to improve them. Before we take a look at the results, lets take a look at the teams for this challenge:
Team Spock (Plotting and Scheming)
Stephen G. (Zef'no)
Daniel Matteson (OKCoyote)
Sean O'Reilly (Jono)
Team Riker (Career Paths)
Michael Moskop (Comicbookhero)
Adam Hegarty (Chewie)
James Monsebroten (Orbin)
Team Kira (Shades of Gray)
James Heaney (BCSWowbagger)
Paddy Tye (KazonPADD)
Matthew Hayes (karonofborg13)
Results
Before we look at the results, I wanted to take a minute to commend and thank the scheduled guest judge for this challenge, Corbin Johnson. One of the contestants made a post on the forums that unintentionally revealed which team he had been a part of; though this contestant quickly deleted the post, Corbin saw it in that window of time. Because this contestant and Corbin were friends, Corbin felt it was the fairest option for him to recuse himself from judging this challenge. This is quite a display of integrity, and we want to publicly thank Corbin for his honesty and the time he had invested in this competition.
Here are the collected results from this challenge:
| Place | Card | Team | Public Score | Allen's Score | Dan's Score | Corbin's Score | Total Score |
| 1 | Plotting and Scheming | Team Spock | 44.35 | 47 | 47.5 | --- | 138.85 |
| 2 | Career Paths | Team Riker | 52.11 | 51 | 52 | --- | 155.11 |
| 3 | Shades of Gray | Team Kira | 43.98 | 52 | 47 | --- | 142.98 |
Congratulations to Team Riker (Adam Hegarty, James Monsebroten, and Michael Mosktop) for their victory with their "Career Path" themed dilemma enhancers. It was a very close race between Team Spock and Team Kira, with less than five (5) points separating the teams. For detailed results, check out the Challenges page of the Make it So subsite. You can find a breakdown of the public votes for each card, as well as all of the comments from the judges and those from the public.
Leaderboard
Here are the current standings for the competition:
| Place | Designer | Individual Score | Challenge #5 Scores | Challenge #6 Scores | Total Score |
| 1 (NC) | Adam Hegarty (Chewie) | 84.56 | 217.60 (Picard) | 155.11 (Riker) | 302.16 |
| 2 (+1) | James Monsebroten (Orbin) | 96.33 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 155.11 (Riker) | 298.98 |
| 3 (+3) | Michael Moskop (Comicbookhero) | 92.13 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 155.11 (Riker) | 297.92 |
| 4 (-2) | Stephen G. (Zef'no) | 77.23 | 217.60 (Picard) | 138.85 (Spock) | 294.83 |
| 5 (-1) | Paddy Tye (KazonPADD) | 76.39 | 217.60 (Picard) | 142.98 (Kira) | 293.99 |
| 6 (-1) | Daniel Matteson (OKCoyote) | 83.63 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 138.85 (Spock) | 286.28 |
| 7 (NC) | Sean O'Reilly (Jono) | 78.36 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 138.85 (Spock) | 284.15 |
| 8 (NC) | James Heaney (BCSWowbagger) | 77.21 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 142.98 (Kira) | 279.86 |
| 9 (NC) | Matthew Hayes (karonofborg13) | 68.36 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 142.98 (Kira) | 274.42 |
Thank you to everyone who participated in voting for this sixth challenge of Make it So! Join the discussion of this challenge and the results on our forums. Challenge #7 will be posted later today. This is a close competition and it seems like any one of our nine (9) contestants might end up in the final challenge. Stay tuned to see who will be The Next First Edition Assistant Designer!
Discuss this article in this thread.
Back to Archive index