 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
All Categories • Continuing Committee • Organized Play • Rules Committee • Deck Designs • Virtual Expansions
Card Extras • Special Events • Tournament Reports • Everything Else • Spotlight Series • Contests
Strategy Articles
Make it So Challenge #8 Results
by Charlie Plaine, Make it So Host
7th April 2014
The eighth and final regular challenge of Make it So is complete, you have voted, and it's time to examine the results! In It's About Time, the teams were asked to create a new Time Location and a new way to time travel, in addition to some temporally themed support cards for their chosen point in time. How well did each team make use of their six (6) cards? Let's take a look at the teams before we look at the results:
Team Scott (Federation/Klingon Border)
Stephen G. (Zef'no)
Paddy Tye (KazonPADD)
James Monsebroten (Orbin)
Team La Forge (Anti-Time Collision Point)
Michael Moskop (Comicbookhero)
Daniel Matteson (OKCoyote)
Matthew Hayes (karonofborg13)
Team O'Brien (Battle of Narendra III)
James Heaney (BCSWowbagger)
Adam Hegarty (Chewie)
Sean O'Reilly (Jono)
Results
Here are the collected results from this challenge:
| Place | Card | Team | Public Score | Allen's Score | Dan's Score | Total Score |
| 1 | Federation/Klingon Border | Team Scott | 50.20 | 50 | 54.5 | 154.70 |
| 2 | Anti-Time Collision Point | Team La Forge | 46.50 | 52 | 43 | 141.50 |
| 3 | Battle of Narendra III | Team O'Brien | 42.01 | 46 | 48.50 | 136.51 |
Congratulations to Team Scott (Stephen G., Paddy Tye, and James Monsebroten) for their victory with their Federation/Klingon Border implementation of the alternate future from "All Good Things." The details on each card, including the comments, will be posted later this week - stay tuned.
Leaderboard
Here are the final standings for the competition:
| Place | Designer | Individual Score | Challenge #5 Scores | Challenge #6 Scores | Challenge #7 Scores | Challenge #8 Scores | Total Score |
| 1 (+1) | James Monsebroten (Orbin) | 92.13 | 217.60 (Picard) | 155.11 (Riker) | 148.22 (Bashir) | 154.70 (Scott) | 755.95 |
| 2 (-1) | Adam Hegarty (Chewie) | 84.56 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 155.11 (Riker) | 155.33 (McCoy) | 136.51 (O'Brien) | 749.11 |
| 3 (+1) | Paddy Tye (KazonPADD) | 77.23 | 217.60 (Picard) | 142.98 (Kira) | 156.40 (Crusher) | 154.70 (Scott) | 748.91 |
| 4 (+1) | Stephen G. (Zef'no) | 96.33 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 138.85 (Spock) | 155.33 (McCoy) | 154.70 (Scott) | 747.86 |
| 5 (-2) | Michael Moskop (Comicbookhero) | 83.63 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 155.11 (Riker) | 156.40 (Crusher) | 141.50 (LaForge) | 739.29 |
| 6 (-) | Daniel Matteson (OKCoyote) | 76.39 | 217.60 (Picard) | 138.85 (Spock) | 148.22 (Bashir) | 141.50 (LaForge) | 722.56 |
| 7 (-) | Sean O'Reilly (Jono) | 78.36 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 138.85 (Spock) | 156.40 (Crusher) | 136.51 (O'Brien) | 715.91 |
| 8 (-) | Matthew Hayes (karonofborg13) | 68.36 | 205.79 (Sisko) | 142.98 (Kira) | 155.33 (McCoy) | 141.50 (LaForge) | 714.23 |
| 9 (-) | James Heaney (BCSWowbagger) | 77.21 | 202.65 (Kirk) | 142.98 (Kira) | 148.22 (Bashir) | 136.51 (O'Brien) | 707.57 |
That means our top two (2) contestants, our finalists, are James Monsebroten (Orbin) and Adam Hegarty (Chewie)! Congrats to James and Adam! These two (2) will advance to The Final Challenge, and will compete head to head to find out who will be the Next First Edition Assistant Designer. We will have more details on The Final Challenge shortly!
We would like to extend a very special thank you to all of our eleven (11) contestants that took their time and energy to participate in this competition. The amount of work required to compete in Make it So can not be overstated, and these contestants have done so with no guarantee of reward. They all deserve a round of applause, no matter where they finished on the leader board. In addition, I would like to extend my personal thanks to our judges that took considerable time and energy to review, comment, and score the contestants cards. All of the hard work done by the contestants, judges, and community of voters is greatly appreciated. Everyone's dedication to and passion for the game is palpabale and wonderful to behold. Meanwhile, we'd like to extend our thanks to everyone who participated in voting for this eighth challenge of Make it So! Join the discussion of this challenge and the results on our forums.
What Comes Next?
The final leg of Make it So is the Final Challenge. Each of the top (2) contestants will be creating their own, fifteen (15) card boutique-style expansions. Contestants will serve as "Lead Designer" for their expansion, starting with recruiting their teams and then managing the team during the entirety of their expansions design. Since this is a challenge with a larger scope, they will have more time than they have had so far to work on their cards. The finalists will have final authority, and thus final responsibility, for their cards.
Once their designs are complete, we will turn to the public once again to review and comment each card, and each submission as a whole. Once the reviews are complete, we will be able to crown a winner and determine who will join the First Edition design team to begin work on an upcoming expansion! We will have more details about the Final Challenge soon, so stay tuned!
Discuss this article in this thread.
Back to Archive index