#587672
Armus wrote: ↑Tue Oct 25, 2022 4:58 pmI could certainly see there being an argument for whether the latter is "skill" dilemma, since it doesn't actually require a specific skill, just that you be extra good at...anything (Rapid Progress does at least require skills, you just have to do some work to find out which ones). A discussion that I'm sure has made the rounds in rules.SirRogue wrote: ↑Tue Oct 25, 2022 4:51 pm...other current-rules skill dilemmas seem to work with the achievement just fine (e.g., "Rapid Progress") which was NOT originally a skill dilemma)...I'm wondering if the wording of Staffing Shortage itself is the issue, as it is a bit unique...Armus wrote: ↑Tue Oct 25, 2022 4:03 pm So I'm not sure if this is a bug or a feature, but adding Staffing Shortage to a dilemma pile breaks the Skilled Labor achievement even though it would appear to be a skill dilemma under current rules.A good question. It is likely this was coded to match however the ruling was at the time (which from your statement sounds like it is different from the "current rules". Because of the nature of the dilemma code structure as I understand it, we cannot change the requirements of an achievement from a fixed point moving forward. Any changes made affect everyone who have ever achieved it. Given that the achievement dates back to 2011, it seems unwise to go in to make changes to grant access to a few more dilemmas.
Is that an issue with the achievement or am I misinterpreting what a skill dilemma is under current rules?
tl;dr, consider it a feature, play as written.
I'm also wondering if it's a database thing, where SS isn't properly coded as a "skill dilemma" ... which would also affect the achievement.That is also possible, in which case, if it is a matter of amending the database to be inline with rules and not having to affect the achievement code itself, . That's more of a @eberlems question though (which is I'm sure why you tagged him).
-----
Sir Rogue I
Emperor, Terran Empire
Achievements Master, TCC
Agent, Section 31
There shall be no peace, as long as Kirk lives...
Sir Rogue I
Emperor, Terran Empire
Achievements Master, TCC
Agent, Section 31
There shall be no peace, as long as Kirk lives...