BCSWowbagger wrote: ↑Tue Mar 21, 2023 4:31 pm
All seasons, best to worst:
This is a fun exercise. While I disagree with specifics, I do see bigger picture stuff that I
do agree with – like VOY 4-7 are all pretty clustered in terms of quality, in contrast with other series.
I'm not up for piecing out an exact list, but here's my tier-list:
Tier 0: TNG 5, DS9 6
Tier 1: TOS 1, TNG 3, 4, DS9 4, 5, 7
Tier 2: TOS 2, 3, TNG 6, 7, DS9 1, 2, 3, VOY 4, 5, 6, 7, ENT 4, LD 1, 2, PRO 1,
Tier 3: TNG 1, 2, VOY 1, 2, 3, ENT 3, DSC 2, 3 (DNF*)
Tier 4: ENT 1 (DNF), DSC 1, PIC 1, ORV** 1 (DNF)
F Tier: PIC 2 (DNF)
DNF = Did Not Finish
Haven't seen: LD 3, DSC 4, PIC 3, SNW 1, ENT 2, TAS 1, 2, ORV 2, 3
*I will fully admit that this is primarily the fault of PIC 2
**It seems silly to include this one, because it makes me want to include BSG-R*** and FIR and EXP and ME, most of which perform better.
***This one would be particularly interesting because it has an inverted tier arc compared to Trek series. BSG-R 1 is definitely tier 0 for me.
Edit: I'm having a very intense feeling of Deja Vu over this post, like you've posted your list before and I reacted to it specifically with a tier list before... but a search of the forums does not turn anything up.
Edit 2: It was Marvel movies.