Discuss all of your questions, concerns, comments and ideas about Second Edition.
User avatar
 
By bhosp
 - Gamma Quadrant
 -  
#413600
The following cards have been inducted into the "Second Edition Hall Of Fame" and may not be included in decks in Hall Of Fame Format events:

By card type:

[D] Dilemmas:
Accelerated Aging
All-Consuming Evil
An Issue of Trust
Back to Basics
Chula: The Chandra
Gomtuu Shock Wave
Hard Time
In Development
Insurrection
Moral Choice
Necessary Execution
Outclassed
Outmatched
Personal Duty
Polywater Intoxication
Secret Identity
The Dreamer and the Dream
Tragic Turn
Tsiolkovsky Infection
Vault of Tomorrow
Well-Prepared Defenses
Where No One Has Gone Before
Whisper In the Dark

[Evt] Events:
A Sight for Sore Eyes
Alvera Tree Ritual
At An Impasse
At What Cost?
Biogenic Weapon
Endangered
Far-Seeing Eyes
Field Studies
Holding Cell
Organized Terrorist Activities
Party Atmosphere
Prejudice and Politics
Point Blank Strike
Power Shift
Security Drills
Surprise Party
These Are the Voyages
U.S.S. Enterprise-J
Unexpected Difficulties

[Equ] Equipment
Emergency Transport Unit

[Int] Interrupts:
Bridge Officer's Test
Covenant
Escape
Grav-Plating Trap
Lustful Distraction
Knowledge and Experience
The Central Command
Uninvited

[H] Missions:
Acquire Illicit Explosives
Aldea, Aid Legendary Civilization
Amnesty Talks
Avert Danger
Brute Force
Cardassia IV, Rescue Prisoners
Ceti Alpha V, Find Lifeless World
Commandeer Prototype
Deliver Evidence
Eliminate Harvesters
Feldomite Rush
Gateway, Historical Research
Geological Survey
Investigate Alien Probe
Investigate Destruction
Investigate Maquis Activity
Investigate Massacre
Kressari Rendezvous
Protect the Escapees
Secure Strategic Base
Selay, Transport Delegations
Survey New World


[Baj] Personnel:
Basso Tromac

[Bor] Personnel:
Annexation Drone

[Car] Personnel:
Mila, Trusted Confidante
Telle, Macet's Aide

[Fed] Personnel:
Chakotay, Bridge Between Two Crews
Guinan, Listener
James T. Kirk, Living Legend
James T. Kirk, Original Thinker
Jaresh-Inyo, Federation President
Leonard H. McCoy, Chief Medical Officer
Leonard H. McCoy, Remarkable Man
Lwaxana Troi, Extravagant Ambassador
Revised Chakotay, Imposturous First Officer
Shankar, Maquis Soldier

[Fer] Personnel:
Quark, Vastly Outnumbered

[Kli] Personnel:
Alexander Rozhenko, K'mtar
K'tal, Senior Council Member
William T. Riker, Exchange Officer

[NA] Personnel:
Amaros, Freedom Fighter
Dukat, Pah-Wraith Puppet
Ezri Tigan
Julian Bashir, Rebel Captain
Morik
Shran, In Archer's Debt
Tolian Soran

[Rom] Personnel:
Donatra, Honorable Commander
Ptol
Tal, Alert Subcommander

[SF] Personnel:
Jonathan Archer, Damaged Captain

[Fed] Ships:
I.K.S. Qel'Poh, H.M.S. Bounty
U.S.S. Centaur, Patrolling Ship
U.S.S. Enterprise-D, Personal Flagship
U.S.S. Excelsior

[Rom] Ships:
Bird-of-Prey
Gal Gath\'thong

By Class

Class of 2017:
Gomtuu Shock Wave
An Issue of Trust
Hard Time
James T. Kirk, Original Thinker
Chakotay, Bridge Between Two Crews

Class of 2018:
All-Consuming Evil
Aldea, Aid Legendary Civilization
Revised Chakotay, Imposturous First Officer
Shran, In Archer's Debt
Julian Bashir, Rebel Captain
These Are the Voyages
Lwaxana Troi, Extravagant Ambassador
Where No One Has Gone Before
Tragic Turn
Cardassia IV, Rescue Prisoners
Personal Duty
Dukat, Pah-Wraith Puppet
Investigate Alien Probe
Survey New World
Security Drills
Knowledge and Experience
Power Shift

Class of 2019:
The Central Command
Gateway, Historical Research
Investigate Maquis Activity
Moral Choice
Uninvited
James T. Kirk, Living Legend
Accelerated Aging
Grav-Plating Trap
At What Cost?
Telle, Macet's Aide
Kressari Rendezvous
The Dreamer and the Dream
Field Studies
Quark, Vastly Outnumbered
U.S.S. Centaur, Patrolling Ship
Investigate Destruction
Protect the Escapees

Class of 2020:
Polywater Intoxication
Bird-of-Prey
Brute Force
Bridge Officer's Test
Leonard H. McCoy, Remarkable Man
Shankar, Maquis Soldier
William T. Riker, Exchange Officer
Amaros, Freedom Fighter
Avert Danger
Geological Survey
In Development
Biogenic Weapon
Guinan, Listener
Ptol
Eliminate Harvesters
Feldomite Rush
Alvera Tree Ritual
At An Impasse
Holding Cell
Unexpected Difficulties
Gal Gath\'thong
Annexation Drone
Investigate Massacre
Outmatched
U.S.S. Enterprise-J
Lustful Distraction
Endangered
U.S.S. Excelsior
Jonathan Archer, Damaged Captain
Acquire Illicit Explosives
Amnesty Talks
Deliver Evidence
Necessary Execution
Whisper In the Dark
Escape
A Sight for Sore Eyes
Point Blank Strike
Morik

Class of 2021:
Back to Basics
Tsiolkovsky Infection
Vault of Tomorrow
Surprise Party
Party Atmosphere
Selay, Transport Delegations
Leonard H. McCoy, Chief Medical Officer
Chula: The Chandra
Outclassed
Secret Identity
Far-Seeing Eyes
Prejudice and Politics
Commandeer Prototype
Secure Strategic Base
Basso Tromac
Donatra, Honorable Commander
Emergency Transport Unit
Alexander Rozhenko, K'mtar
Ezri Tigan
Tolian Soran
Tal, Alert Subcommander
Insurrection
Well-Prepared Defenses
Organized Terrorist Activities
Covenant
Ceti Alpha V, Find Lifeless World
Mila, Trusted Confidante
Jaresh-Inyo, Federation President
K'tal, Senior Council Member
I.K.S. Qel'Poh, H.M.S. Bounty
U.S.S. Enterprise-D, Personal Flagship
User avatar
 
By Danny (Daniel Giddings)
 - Gamma Quadrant
 -  
2E British National Runner-Up 2021
#413669
As the list gets bigger, could we get it put into alphabetical order and/or split into categories (Dilemmas, Events, Missions, etc)?

Also, if this becomes a CC endorsed format, would we be able to get a "Hall of Fame" filter added to the Card Pool drop down on the 2E Search page?
User avatar
 
By Armus (Brian Sykes)
 - The Center of the Galaxy
 -  
Regent
Community Contributor
  Trek Masters 1E Champion 2023
User avatar
 
By monty42 (Benjamin Liebich)
 - Delta Quadrant
 -  
Continuing Committee Member - Retired
2E World Quarter-Finalist 2023
Chancellor
2E European Continental Runner-Up 2023
2E German National Champion 2022
#413745
KillerB wrote:Unless Nate becomes the new DoOP....
You're living in a Trump-world now. Everything's possible...
User avatar
 
By KillerB (John Corbett)
 - The Center of the Galaxy
 -  
Continuing Committee Member - Retired
Architect
Community Contributor
#413749
monty42 wrote: Everything's possible...
I came down hard on Maggie and Ross a few months back. A little too hard. They where basically asking me to trust the decision making process on selecting a new DoOP. But that was also during the PoR, after the Ken firing, where faith my in CC decision making was at a low point.

Let be optimistic about the future.
User avatar
 
By nobthehobbit (Daniel Pareja)
 - The Center of the Galaxy
 -  
Moderator
#415008
edgeofhearing wrote:
KillerB wrote:It's time to send Davies, Kahmis, Excelsior, K'vort, The [Rom] Stooges and some others to the retirement home.
I'll honestly never get tired of seeing non-uniques without gametext, no matter how ubiquitous.
Well then we can at least retire the stooges, right?
User avatar
 
By KillerB (John Corbett)
 - The Center of the Galaxy
 -  
Continuing Committee Member - Retired
Architect
Community Contributor
#415106
Naetor wrote:I might be weird, but I think the non-uniques with little or no gametext are the best cards.
It's not weird at all. I'm saying let's find more non-unique/mission foundations then just Davies/GeoMissions and Kahmis/Leadership-Security-Strength.

If we can't find more, then I ask the designers to pitch more.

(Foundation = I don't mean a non-unique with ALL of a mission skills, like Kahmis. That's a design sin. But two out three ain't bad. I think having a deck where two non-uniques get you all your missions skill, maybe except one, is acceptable.)
User avatar
 
By Danny (Daniel Giddings)
 - Gamma Quadrant
 -  
2E British National Runner-Up 2021
#415108
KillerB wrote:It's not weird at all. I'm saying let's find more non-unique/mission foundations then just Davies/GeoMissions and Kahmis/Leadership-Security-Strength.

If we can't find more, then I ask the designers to pitch more.

(Foundation = I don't mean a non-unique with ALL of a mission skills, like Kahmis. That's a design sin. But two out three ain't bad. I think having a deck where two non-uniques get you all your missions skill, maybe except one, is acceptable.)
I know this isn't strictly what you were after (this looks at weenie missions specialists, rather than non-unique 'almost all the skills') but I might be something to start from.
User avatar
 
By pschrader
 - Beta Quadrant
 -  
2E American National Runner-Up 2023
#415121
KillerB wrote:
Naetor wrote:I might be weird, but I think the non-uniques with little or no gametext are the best cards.
It's not weird at all. I'm saying let's find more non-unique/mission foundations then just Davies/GeoMissions and Kahmis/Leadership-Security-Strength.

If we can't find more, then I ask the designers to pitch more.

(Foundation = I don't mean a non-unique with ALL of a mission skills, like Kahmis. That's a design sin. But two out three ain't bad. I think having a deck where two non-uniques get you all your missions skill, maybe except one, is acceptable.)
I know he's not exactly what you're talking about, but I love Garvey and Rigel X.
User avatar
 
By nobthehobbit (Daniel Pareja)
 - The Center of the Galaxy
 -  
Moderator
#415812
Just as a note so people can maybe start thinking about what they want to nominate next year, here's some of the most heavily played cards from sets released in 2009 (Raise the Stakes, This Side of Paradise, Legacy, Allegiance):

He Wasn't Nice
Miner Revolt
Occupational Hazards
Bridge Officer's Test
Ptol

Polywater Intoxication

Quark, Vastly Outnumbered
Mis-seeds

Procedural note: The 1E Rules Committee can't ch[…]

Frool has also recently been used with Holoprog[…]

I got the FW against @doctorjoya 100-45. It was […]

We are a week and a day out from this year&rsquo[…]