In all fairness, that BradyGames "strategy guide" gave a top 100 cards list at a time when there were only 363 cards in the whole game. Which may have been a questionable choice, but I can actually see
Wind Dancer being in the top third of cards if Premiere is all you're dealing with. There weren't a lot of walls then(
Shaka being a huge exception)...
Impassable Door is far weaker, Hologram Ruse can be overcome by just throwing more bodies at it. The list of playable Premiere personnel who could pass Wind Dancer isn't that long, although of course the Feds walk through it the easiest (Worf, Data, Picard, and Riker all pass it).
Roga Danar or a weapon would be the best bet for all the others.
Alien Groupie I can't defend. Maybe combo with
Thine Own Self to permanently put someone away? But the random selection still makes it weak.
If I remember right, they put
Data Laughing in the top 100 cards list which was pure indulgence (at first you could only get the card by buying the book) and completely indefensible. Two-thirds of the card was a broken link, and as for the rest you'd rather stock
Hugh or a Kevin 99.99999% of the time.