#587616
Probably one fact I've already discussed with James and was a discussion at our latest tournament:
When actually does a mission attempt ends? To be more precise - when can you check the passing condition of TwtF? Can you check it, if there is no crew or away team left because everyone is stopped (f.e. attempt with only one personnel)? Can you then check with NO ONE LEFT if you pass the requirements of that dilemma and then make a to a NON EXISTING crew or away team which joins that NON EXISTING crew or away team and continues that mission?
IMO this is the most important key point that needs clarification in the rules! If the whole crew or away team is stopped by the first part of a dilemma, does this crew or away team even "continues" to a probable second part of that same dilemma (a passing requirement or something else), or is the mission attempt simply over in that instance, when everybody is stopped? The phrase "Discard dilemma" should override everything above of course, because of the meaning of that phrase
Of course, if one guy continues, no DDOY is played to stop that guy, a can bring you the proper to pass that dilemma (with no more response window for DDOY)...
When actually does a mission attempt ends? To be more precise - when can you check the passing condition of TwtF? Can you check it, if there is no crew or away team left because everyone is stopped (f.e. attempt with only one personnel)? Can you then check with NO ONE LEFT if you pass the requirements of that dilemma and then make a to a NON EXISTING crew or away team which joins that NON EXISTING crew or away team and continues that mission?
IMO this is the most important key point that needs clarification in the rules! If the whole crew or away team is stopped by the first part of a dilemma, does this crew or away team even "continues" to a probable second part of that same dilemma (a passing requirement or something else), or is the mission attempt simply over in that instance, when everybody is stopped? The phrase "Discard dilemma" should override everything above of course, because of the meaning of that phrase
Of course, if one guy continues, no DDOY is played to stop that guy, a can bring you the proper to pass that dilemma (with no more response window for DDOY)...
GARRY GLITTER 2014 (3 of 3)
Official Neil Timmons Carrier
1E Biermeister 2010
Tractor Beam Award 2010
Official Neil Timmons Carrier
1E Biermeister 2010
Tractor Beam Award 2010