trekcc.org

The ruling is that you can do something before or after any action. Consuming is an action, so you can do something before or after that. Placing a dilemma on a mission is an action, so you can do it before that. Randomly selecting a personnel to be stopped is an action, so you can do it before or after. You can't do it in the middle of an action, ie after the selection but before the stop, save for something that specifically says "about to be stopped" or "has been selected". It is written as a single action.

Keller wrote:The ruling is that you can do something before or after any action. Consuming is an action, so you can do something before or after that. Placing a dilemma on a mission is an action, so you can do it before that. Randomly selecting a personnel to be stopped is an action, so you can do it before or after. You can't do it in the middle of an action, ie after the selection but before the stop, save for something that specifically says "about to be stopped" or "has been selected". It is written as a single action.

Is returning the dilemma to the dilemma pile or placing it under the mission an action that you can do something before? Or look at it as doing something at the end of the dilemma.


Jared

Mugato wrote:Is returning the dilemma to the dilemma pile or placing it under the mission an action that you can do something before?

yes

Does this affect the way, for example, The Borg Queen, Guardian of the Hive can interact with dilemmas?
I was always under the impression that after a selection like on Pinned Down, that the Queen didn't have a chance to respond/swap drones anymore since there's no more text to execute.

So is she still facing the dilemma right before it gets placed underneath the mission (or somewhere else) or can only the act of having the dilemma placed somewhere be reacted upon (i.e., Quarantine)?

Thanks.
-dave

ikeya wrote:Does this affect the way, for example, The Borg Queen, Guardian of the Hive can interact with dilemmas?
I was always under the impression that after a selection like on Pinned Down, that the Queen didn't have a chance to respond/swap drones anymore since there's no more text to execute.

So is she still facing the dilemma right before it gets placed underneath the mission (or somewhere else) or can only the act of having the dilemma placed somewhere be reacted upon (i.e., Quarantine)?

According to Keller's ruling, after the last sentence is a valid time to respond.

That is exactly why I am for being more strict with the interpretation. I understand, but disagree with the ruling.